Sunday, December 30, 2007

And after all is said and done...

I had one of my more unusual religious conversations yesterday. My friend is Protestant, although Catholic educated, and we both enjoy a good discussion involving different viewpoints when intelligently voiced. We have similar views on the general idea--love others and love God. It's figuring out what that can mean in the specifics where we come into differences of opinion. I'll admit that I enjoyed it. There was something good about having to voice and explain my reasons for considering certain actions to be outside of my moral comfort zone--whether immediate treatment of people, financial decisions, or personal relationships.

Was it a conversation I was expecting to have in depth right then? No, not at all, especially as some of my views are still in flux. It felt good though to have to think on the fly and explain why I had held my old views, in order to make them something real and adult rather than simply childish ideals in a modern world. One of my favorite professors used to stress that unclear writing was an indication of unclear thought. He felt that you couldn't understand a book or an idea until you tried to engage it in writing or vocal response. As evidenced by my blogs--I agree with that view. The world makes far more sense when I attempt to engage it with words. Those apologetics were on to something==although I don't agree with them on everything. I have some major issues with Saint Augustine.

I think the best thing about the conversation was that it has been quite a long time since I entered into a serious religious discussion with someone who disagreed with me and yet really knew what he or she was talking about. I know a lot of people who disagree with me and can say "uh, because the Pope says gays are sinful!" but then many of those people are shocked that the rules about not eating shrimp and wearing polycotton blends are right next to most of those prohibitions against homosexuality (in case you can't tell, I think that just as we now eat shrimp and wear polycotton blends, we need to get past the whole "condemn those who love regardless of a person's physical nature"--we're more than bodies, aren't we? but that's not the point of this post...)
It was so pleasant to have a discussion about changing morals and where different rules come from with someone who is aware of the vast tradition of Christianity and all the different ideas that have come and gone. Having my friend bring up the aesthetics and various excommunications was just...refreshing. I get very tired of "well it's wrong, because I just think it is" in the same way that I get tired of "well that's just old fashioned" as a condemnation of a belief or moral code.
Belief does come down to faith, but the choices we make...if we want to make a difference in the lives and choices of others, it helps if there's some reason to those choices. An understanding of where we've come from and the tradition out of which we're working is useful if you want to engage someone in a debate where the parties don't agree on everything. Otherwise it turns into a senate floor shouting match.

Saturday, December 1, 2007

judgment

I was reminded of judgment this past week when a friend judged another friend harshly for a choice I supported. The choice she advocated was one that would have bothered my conscience. I would have tried not to judge if that choice had been made, but I think I would have been unsuccessful.

We judge so often today. It's part of being a girl, to some extent. I don't think that the little judgments are quite as harmful as movies such as Mean Girls would make us think. I think we judge more like the heroine of Saved when she laughs at the "popular" 'yay God' girl. If you haven't seen Saved, I highly recommend it. It's a film that reminds us to love one another and to not judge too harshly--we're all doing the best we can.

If you haven't seen it, basic plot is that a conservative Christian girl who has always been taught that homosexuality is a sin tries to "save" her boyfriend by having sex with him. He gets shipped to "straight camp" while she ends up pregnant. The rest of the film is her journey through reconciling her beliefs with her situation.

How many people see their beliefs get knocked out of line by life being just a little different than expected? My friend and I gave some help to a guy whose car had broken down on the beltway the other night. My friend refers to her religious beliefs as "metaphysical" and she does not mean Aristotle.
She was the one who suggested that we pull over and help the guy. When she made a joke about giving birth to the new Jesus after he joked about her pairing with men named Joe, the guy seemed offended.
Maybe I'm confused, but maybe making a joke about giving birth to Jesus isn't too bad when it's coming from the girl who made sure that you were safe and helped you not be stranded on the highway.
Also...I think God has a sense of humor and can laugh with us when we poke fun at religion.

I'd like to think that the guy was better off for seeing that nonChristians can be just as nice as Christians (nicer sometimes, actually). Maybe it'll remind him that love isn't so much about judging as it is about welcoming.

As the film says, if God wanted us all to be exactly the same, why would He have made us all so different?